Menu Close

Text Messages and Social Media Evidence in Maryland Stalking and Harassment Cases

Quick answer: In Maryland stalking and harassment prosecutions, text messages, DMs, and social media posts are frequently the core evidence — but the law rarely treats a single message as enough. Maryland’s stalking statute requires a “malicious course of conduct,” and its harassment statute generally requires that the contact continue after a clear warning to stop, so prosecutors typically need a pattern of messages, not one bad text. How that evidence gets used also depends on details people don’t expect: whether a screenshot holds up the same as the original message, whether deleted texts can be recovered, and — often the most contested issue — whether the state can actually prove who sent a given message. Maryland’s authentication standard for this kind of evidence has shifted over the past decade toward a more flexible, circumstantial approach, making it easier for prosecutors to get messages admitted but also giving defense attorneys more specific angles to challenge them.

When Can Messages Become Evidence?

Text messages, direct messages, and social media posts become evidence the moment they’re relevant to conduct the law actually prohibits. Two Maryland statutes do most of the work here. Stalking, under Md. Code, Criminal Law § 3-802, is defined as a malicious course of conduct — approaching, pursuing, or contacting someone — done with the intent to place them in reasonable fear of serious bodily injury, assault, rape, sexual offense, false imprisonment, or death, or with the intent to cause serious emotional distress. Critically, the statute expressly covers conduct carried out through electronic communication, not just in-person contact. Separately, misuse of electronic communication, under Md. Code, Criminal Law § 3-805, targets a malicious course of conduct carried out specifically through electronic means — texts, emails, social media, and similar platforms — that alarms or seriously annoys another person, done with intent to harass and without a legal purpose.

Both statutes turn heavily on the actual content, timing, and pattern of digital communication, which is why messages so often become the centerpiece of these cases. That’s a narrower and more specific question than the broader digital-evidence issues — warrant requirements, cell phone searches, GPS tracking — covered in our overview of digital evidence in Maryland criminal cases. This article focuses specifically on how text and social media evidence functions as proof in stalking and harassment cases once it’s in play.

Does One Message Count as Harassment?

Usually not, at least not under the stalking and general harassment statutes specifically. Section 3-802’s stalking offense requires a “malicious course of conduct” — language that, by definition, points to repeated or ongoing behavior rather than a single isolated act. Maryland’s separate harassment statute, Md. Code, Criminal Law § 3-803, is even more explicit about this: it requires that the harassing conduct continue after the person has received a reasonable warning or request to stop. A single unwanted text, without more, typically doesn’t satisfy either standard on its own.

That doesn’t mean one message is automatically legally irrelevant. A single message that contains an explicit, specific threat can potentially support other charges entirely — separate from stalking or harassment — depending on exactly what it says. And a single message can still matter as part of a broader pattern, establishing the starting point of a course of conduct that continues afterward. But as a general rule, prosecutors build stalking and harassment cases around a sequence of contact over time, not a single data point, which is exactly why the pattern and context surrounding any one message tend to matter as much as the message itself.

Why Context Matters

A text message or DM read in isolation, stripped of everything around it, can be seriously misleading in either direction. The same blunt or angry message might look threatening on its own but read very differently next to a string of messages showing an ongoing mutual argument, a request that contact stop, or a pattern of escalation. Courts and prosecutors look at the full exchange — the relationship between the parties, prior communications, whether a warning to stop was ever given, how the recipient responded, and how the tone and frequency of contact changed over time.

This cuts both ways. Context can turn what looks like a single overreaction into evidence of a genuine pattern of escalating conduct. It can just as easily show that a message pulled out of a much longer, more mutual exchange looks far more alarming standing alone than it did in the actual conversation. Anyone facing a stalking or harassment allegation built on message evidence should assume the full thread — not just the messages the other side chooses to highlight — will end up mattering to how the case is evaluated.

Screenshots vs. Original Messages

A screenshot is generally admissible in Maryland courts as a duplicate of the original message, and in most cases it’s treated as being just as reliable as the original for evidentiary purposes. Maryland’s rules on original writings generally allow duplicates to be used in place of an original unless there’s a genuine question raised about the duplicate’s authenticity or it would be unfair to rely on it under the circumstances.

That said, “generally admissible” isn’t the same as “ideal.” A screenshot captures how a message looked on a screen at one moment, but it can lose important information the original digital file retains — exact timestamps, sender account details, metadata showing whether a message was edited, or the surrounding messages that got cropped out of frame. Screenshots can also be altered, which is precisely the kind of “genuine question about authenticity” that can require more than the screenshot alone to resolve. Whenever possible, preserving the actual device, app, or account data — not just a screenshot of it — gives both sides a stronger evidentiary foundation and reduces the chance the evidence gets challenged on authenticity grounds later.

Deleted Messages and Device Evidence

Deleting a text or a social media message doesn’t reliably make it disappear from every place it exists. Messaging platforms, social media companies, and phone carriers routinely retain data — including content a user has deleted from their own device — and that data can often be recovered through forensic extraction, cloud backups, or a subpoena to the platform itself. Our digital evidence overview covers this in more depth: deleted content is frequently recoverable, and law enforcement increasingly knows how and where to look for it.

This matters in two directions. For someone alleging stalking or harassment, messages they believe were deleted by the other party aren’t necessarily gone as evidence. And for someone accused, deleting messages after learning they’re under investigation — or after a protective order has been filed — carries real risk: it can be framed as consciousness of guilt, and in some circumstances can constitute a separate offense like evidence tampering or obstruction, independent of whatever the underlying stalking or harassment allegation involves.

Proving Who Actually Sent the Message

This is often the single most contested issue in these cases, and Maryland’s approach to it has changed significantly. In Griffin v. State (2011), the Maryland high court took a strict view, rejecting the idea that circumstantial details alone — a name, a birthdate, a profile photo — were enough to authenticate a social media post as belonging to a particular person, given how easily an account can be faked or accessed by someone other than its apparent owner. The court pointed to narrower, more direct ways of proving authorship: asking the purported author directly, forensically examining their device, or obtaining records from the platform itself linking the account and post to that specific person.

That standard shifted in Sublet v. State (2015), which adopted a more flexible test: whether a reasonable juror could conclude, based on the evidence presented, that the message or post is what it’s claimed to be — not whether every alternative explanation has been ruled out. Under this “reasonable juror” approach, Maryland courts now regularly consider a range of circumstantial factors together, including:

  • Biographical or account details that tie the message to a specific person
  • Contacts, friends, or connections associated with the account
  • A screen name or handle that reflects the person’s actual identity
  • Content referencing specific facts or events only that person would plausibly know
  • Timing that lines up with where the person was or what they were doing
  • Distinctive language patterns — phrasing, spelling, or punctuation habits
  • How the recipient responded at the time, in a way that shows they treated the message as coming from that person

No single factor is automatically enough, but combined, they can meet the reasonable-juror standard even without a confession or a forensic device search. For someone contesting a stalking or harassment charge, this is frequently where the real legal fight happens — not whether the message itself was sent, but whether the state can actually connect it to the accused.

Social-Media Posts and DMs

Public social media posts and private direct messages raise related but distinct issues. A public post — visible to anyone, requiring no special access — generally carries fewer privacy protections and can be captured directly as evidence without the same legal process required for private communications. Private DMs, by contrast, typically require a subpoena or similar legal process directed at the platform, since they aren’t publicly accessible the way an open post is.

For stalking and harassment cases specifically, both categories often work together to establish the “course of conduct” these statutes require. A pattern of public posts referencing a specific person, combined with private messages sent directly to them, can together paint a picture of sustained, targeted conduct that neither category would fully establish on its own. Platforms generally retain this content — including posts and messages a user later deletes or an account the user later deactivates — which is part of why social media evidence has become such a significant factor in how these cases get built and defended.

Protective Orders and Criminal Investigations

The same texts, DMs, and social media posts that support a stalking or harassment charge frequently show up in a parallel civil case as well: a petition for a Maryland protective order. Because a protective order case is decided under the lower preponderance-of-the-evidence standard rather than the criminal case’s beyond-a-reasonable-doubt standard, the same message evidence can carry real weight in the civil proceeding even before — or regardless of whether — it ever supports a criminal conviction.

This overlap means message evidence gathered or disclosed in one proceeding doesn’t necessarily stay contained to that proceeding. Someone facing both a protective order petition and a related criminal investigation involving text or social media evidence benefits from treating the two as connected from the outset, rather than responding to each one separately without accounting for how they affect each other. Our criminal defense practice page has more on how we approach cases where digital evidence plays a central role.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I be charged with stalking or harassment over a single text message? Generally, no. Maryland’s stalking statute requires a malicious “course of conduct,” and its harassment statute requires that the conduct continue after a warning to stop — both point to a pattern rather than one isolated message. A single sufficiently threatening message could potentially support a different charge, but stalking and harassment charges specifically are usually built on repeated contact over time.

Is a screenshot enough to prove what a text message said? Generally, yes — Maryland treats duplicates like screenshots as admissible in place of the original unless there’s a genuine question about authenticity or it would be unfair to rely on the copy. But screenshots can be cropped, edited, or missing metadata the original file retains, so preserving the underlying message or account data alongside any screenshot is the stronger approach.

If I deleted the messages, can they still be used against me? Often, yes. Platforms, carriers, and cloud backups frequently retain data even after it’s deleted from a device, and forensic recovery is common in these cases. Deleting messages after learning about an investigation or protective order can also raise separate legal risks of its own.

How does the state prove I actually sent a particular message? Maryland courts apply what’s known as the “reasonable juror” standard from Sublet v. State — looking at circumstantial factors like account details, language patterns, timing, and content referencing facts only the sender would know, rather than requiring direct proof like a confession or device search. This is frequently one of the most contested issues in a stalking or harassment case built on message evidence.

Can the same messages be used in both a protective order case and a criminal case? Yes. The same text or social media evidence can support both a civil protective order petition, decided under the lower preponderance-of-the-evidence standard, and a separate criminal stalking or harassment charge, which requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt. The two proceedings are legally distinct but often draw on the same underlying evidence.

(301) 251-2772